<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1"?>
<?xml-stylesheet type="text/xsl" href="ecal071-grades.xsl"?>

<exercise>
	<title>ECAL071 EX5 Grades</title>
	<header>Assignment 5 Grades</header>	
	<text>			
		Click on the authors to see their work. 
		Click on the grade to toggle my comments on and off.		
	</text>

	<works>		

    <work>
      <authors>liadi, mazory</authors>
      <url>http://www.liad.biz/ecal/ex5/</url>
      <general>Very good report, nice presentation of the work done.</general>
      <comments>
        <comment>good-analyses</comment>
      </comments>
    </work>

		<work>
			<authors>beckerli, ohanaar</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~beckerli/Ass5/CA.htm</url>
			<general>Very good report!</general>
			<comments>
				<id>desc-process</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
			<authors>bas, benichay</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~benichay/Ex5/</url>
			<general>Good work, and good results.</general>
			<comments>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
      <!-- HOF (0) -->
			<authors>eliyahuu, kertis</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~eliyahuu/ass5/</url>
			<general>Very good report</general>
			<comments>
				<id>fitness</id>
				<id>density-inputs</id>
        <id>good-analyses</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
      <!-- HOF (1) -->
			<authors>ronav</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~ronav/ecal/ex5</url>
			<general>Very good work, high quality report</general>
			<comments>
				<id>good-analyses</id>
        <id>ruleset-time</id>
        <id>fitness</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
			<authors>ilankad, wolfsonk</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~wolfsonk/GA/ex5/</url>
			<general>Good work, though your space-time diagrams for the synchronization problem
            are not visible online, at least not with Firefox/LINUX (found them after a while, hidden in
            your index.files folder... don't trust MS-Word htmls!)
      </general>
			<comments>
				<id>fitness</id>
				<id>ruleset-time</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>

			<authors>abirs, yaakovog</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~abirs/evo/ass5/</url>
			<general>Very good work, and good report. Nice graphic plots.</general>
			<comments>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
			<authors>aharob, blesser</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~aharob/Ex5</url>
			<general>Good work!</general>
			<comments>
				<id>ruleset-time</id>
				<id>good-analyses</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
			<authors>amitbenb, nigri</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~nigri/evoltask5.htm</url>
			<general>Good work, and good report.</general>
			<comments>
				<id>no-fitness</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>95</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
			<authors>alexta, zhok</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~alexta</url>
			<general>Your work is good, yet the report is a bit too brief.</general>
			<comments>
				<id>no-space-time</id>
				<id>no-conclusions</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>93</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
      <!-- HOF (2) -->
			<authors>lisse, suissad</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~suissad/ECAL071/ex5/doc5</url>
			<general>Excellent work!</general>
			<comments>
				<id>good-analyses</id>
				<id>fitness</id>
        <id>ruleset-time</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
      <!-- HOF (2) -->
			<authors>meltzerh, zeharias</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~zeharias/Assignment5/ass5.htm</url>
			<general>Very good work and report. Good introduction and description of the problems.</general>
			<comments>
				<id>fitness</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>

		<work>
      <!-- HOF (0) -->
			<authors>einavbit, jasminme</authors>
			<url>http://www.cs.bgu.ac.il/~jasminme/ECAL071/Exe5/Exe5</url>
			<general>Very good work and report.</general>
			<comments>
				<id>fitness</id>
				<id>ruleset-time</id>
        <id>good-analyses</id>
			</comments>
			<grade>100</grade>
		</work>
  </works>

		<!--

		<work>
			<authors></authors>
			<url></url>
			<general></general>
			<comments>
				<id></id>
				<id></id>
			</comments>
			<grade>???</grade>
		</work>


		-->

  
  <comments>
		<comment id="good-plots">			
			<text>Very good plots and graphs!</text>	
		</comment>

		<comment id="good-analyses">			
			<text>Good analyses of the evolved results.</text>
		</comment>

    <comment id="desc-process">
      <text>Good description for progress of work</text>
    </comment>

    <comment id="ruleset-time">
      <text>The ruleset vs. Time graph is very nice and provides good understanding of the automaton improvenemt through the evolution progress.
      </text>
    </comment>

    <comment id="fitness">
      <text>Nice tweaks made to fitness function</text>
    </comment>

    <comment id="density-inputs">
      <text>Good experiments with input states for the density problem</text>
    </comment>

    <comment id="no-fitness">
      <text>Missing: A description of the fitness used in the density and synchronization problems</text>
      <score>-5</score>
    </comment>
	
    <comment id="no-conclusions">
      <text>You could have elaborated some more in the conclusions part</text>
      <score>-2</score>
    </comment>

    <comment id="no-space-time">
      <text>Missing: space-time diagrams</text>
      <score>-5</score>
    </comment>

		<!--

		<comment id="comment">			
			<text></text>
			<score></score>
		</comment>
		-->
	</comments>
</exercise>
